The fourth poem in the Class XI WBCHSE English B syllabus is 'Brotherhood' composed by the legendary,noble prize winning Mexican poet Octavio Paz.The poem has been written on a search for the realisation that no matter how little every human being in this huge universe is,every little being still has a very special and unique place in the scheme of the universe.
Paz himself drew from Marxism,Surrealism( Surrealism is a cultural movement that began in the early 1920s, and is best known for its visual artworks and writings. The aim was to "resolve the previously contradictory conditions of dream and reality.")
and Extentialism (Existentialism is a philosophy that emphasizes individual existence, freedom and choice. It is the view that humans define their own meaning in life, and try to make rational decisions despite existing in an irrational universe.).
The juxtaposition of concepts as diverse as the three make his works remarkably unique and effective in the reader's eye.
Brotherhood : Homage To Claudius Ptolemy
(Credit : Source)
I am a man: little do I last
and the night is enormous.
But I look up:
the stars write.
Unknowing I understand:
I too am written,
and at this very moment
someone spells me out.
(Original Photograph from Photograph Source)
Poem Analysis,Summarisation And Explanation
The poem has been written in free verse and as such,this is a part of modern poetry rather than the last three poems we have covered from the syllabus,all of which were more or less inspired from romanticism and associated values.
This poem,as can be readily understood,is based mostly on extentialism.It has been written as homage to Claudius Ptolemy,who was a Greco-Egyptian writer of Alexandria, known as a mathematician, astronomer, geographer, astrologer, and poet of a single epigram in the Greek Anthology who lived in Rome around 100 AD.This is perhaps because of Ptolemy's contribution in making us understand the concept of the universe based on which Paz composed this poem.
The first four lines of the poem neatly offsets in the last four lines. The opening line describes how an individual pales into insignificance as a mere being in this vast universe.
When this mere being looks up at the sky,he is able to read the inspiration and knowledge that stars are able to write.
Starry Night Over the Rhone, 1888, oil on canvas by Van Gogh
And almost unknowingly,he realises that the purpose of his life too,has been written in the sky.This act of writing is not casual,it is deliberate in nature.And now that he realises this,he is able to create a definiteness that assures him of his own identity,assures him of visibility within the mighty vastness.
Special Credit : 'Mindscapes : Higher Secondary English Selections' Printed by Orient Blackswan on behalf of West Bengal Council of Higher Secondary Education (WBCHSE).
44 Comments
It was great... Should be published at the end of the book replacing the current one.
ReplyDeleteGlad that you think so! Thank You!
DeleteI cant understand through this blog how the title "Brotherhood" is signified?
DeleteI think I as a humanbeing has an identity in this vast universe. Stars are helping us in making out the idea that we are not alone in this universe.There is a relation of brtherhood among us all. So we have an identity .When the poet was hopelessly searching of this relation ,he looked at stars and they embraced him.Even scientists hava a query 'Are we alone in this earth?' Every ventuure tries to seek the existence of reality.
DeleteHello 'Anonymous', I'm sorry for getting back this late. I think 'Unknown' has answered the query with some very valid insight.
DeleteHowever, if you're writing an answer from an academic perspective, I think a little more attention to the way you're writing things helps. So, for instance, you might like to say - Human beings, as individual creatures inhabiting the planet are blessed with the capability to 'sense'. Among the vast array of feelings and sensations that they can perceive and experience, that of vulnerability is one. Like Carl Sagan says, "Tiny creatures like us can bear the vastness only through love." By looking at the infinite, and trying to introspect into the endless dimensions that constitute it, we might get to realise that we, as human beings are not alone. The collective conscious of 'being' comes from the existence itself. We somehow resemble the night sky lined by tiny, little stars. We, as fellow human being, in relation to other people, are therefore associated from times immemorial. The association is eternal, is inevitable, like the predetermined concept of destiny. That is perhaps why the poem has been named 'Brotherhood'.
Thank you very much.you helped me a lot
DeleteThank you for the help..It helped me a lot..
ReplyDeleteYou're very welcome!
DeleteWasn't Ptolemy the one who offered to explain the movements of astral bodies through his theory of the eight celestial spheres with the earth at the centre? The Christian church endorsed this geocentric--and implicitly anthropocentric-- view of the universe for obvious reasons. Interestingly, Brotherhood also presents a universe where Man has a special significance- not as the nucleus of the Universe, but as a being whose consciousness resonates with the distant stars across abysses of darkness. He is intensely aware of the finiteness of his existence, and yet can feel the bonds of brotherhood with the infinite.
ReplyDeleteYeah, even though I am intrigued to talk more about the evils shared by 'religion' through ages, I think the poem somehow satisfies our eternal longing for understanding infinite to a certain extent. And Paz was Marxist in his life, so I'd also believe he didn't really pay much attention to Ptolemy's 'errors' that were later manifested as 'truth' by the church in order to retain hegemony and hence, power.
DeleteThank you
ReplyDeleteYou're welcome!
DeleteThank you. But whay the title "BROTHERHOOD"? What does the title stands for?
ReplyDelete*Why
DeleteHuman beings, as individual creatures inhabiting the planet are blessed with the capability to 'sense'. Among the vast array of feelings and sensations that they can perceive and experience, that of vulnerability is one. Like Carl Sagan says, "Tiny creatures like us can bear the vastness only through love." By looking at the infinite, and trying to introspect into the endless dimensions that constitute it, we might get to realise that we, as human beings are not alone. The collective conscious of 'being' comes from the existence itself. We somehow resemble the night sky lined by tiny, little stars. We, as fellow human being, in relation to other people, are therefore associated from times immemorial. The association is eternal, is inevitable, like the predetermined concept of destiny. That is perhaps why the poem has been named 'Brotherhood'.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI need a fulfillment summary note on this poem.plz
ReplyDeleteWhat do you actually mean by 'a fulfillment summary note'?
DeleteI want to know why is human life very short
ReplyDelete"Who are you, who am I?/ To know the reason why/ Some are born, some men die/ Beneath an infinite sky..."
DeleteIs dis poem has an open ending or close ending
ReplyDeleteI do agree that the poem is based on the philosopphy of extentialism and do portrays the clear idea of our existence in this vast universe.But how does the brotherhood is created??? Are the stars showing us about the brotherhood or
ReplyDeleteIs like a mirror ; whem stars are "spelling you" "the writter" and "the writen" become a brotherhood...
DeleteSorry my english is not the best....and by the way Paz wasn't exactly a marxist at the end of his life he use to debate against marxism.
This is such valuable information! Thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteGTPL Hathway Limited
Adani Power Ltd
HSBC Holdings PLC
HDFC Life Ltd
Technologistan is the popoular and most trustworthy resource for technology, telecom, business and auto news in Pakistan
ReplyDeleteif you want to store a copy of the playlist or import it to Restaurants Coupons Canada computer so that both computers have the same playlist
ReplyDeleteI worked at PTE Coaching Jalandhar, and one day in my spare time, I read the poem "Brotherhood." I feel brotherhood in this poem when they feel affection and loyalty for those with whom they share a common interest. As a symbol of brotherhood, flowers were thrown into the river that separates the two countries.
ReplyDeleteIt's great to read stories and articles. Thank you for sharing this.
ReplyDeleteThis knowledge is so important! I appreciate you sharing!
ReplyDeleteI am appreciative of your blog. Wonderful.
ReplyDeleteI gratefully acknowledge your blog. Excellent.
ReplyDeleteIğdır
ReplyDeleteAdana
Karabük
Diyarbakır
Antep
ZX8UCK
Ankara
ReplyDeleteVan
Hakkari
Edirne
Yozgat
2GR
kayseri evden eve nakliyat
ReplyDeleteantalya evden eve nakliyat
izmir evden eve nakliyat
nevÅŸehir evden eve nakliyat
kayseri evden eve nakliyat
DF4F
FB62D
ReplyDeleteTrabzon Lojistik
Elazığ Evden Eve Nakliyat
Artvin Evden Eve Nakliyat
Kırşehir Evden Eve Nakliyat
Konya Lojistik
E07D3
ReplyDeleteÇerkezköy Cam Balkon
Silivri DuÅŸa Kabin Tamiri
Van Evden Eve Nakliyat
MaraÅŸ Evden Eve Nakliyat
Ağrı Evden Eve Nakliyat
4C1CF
ReplyDeleteKilis Şehir İçi Nakliyat
Yozgat Parça Eşya Taşıma
Osmaniye Lojistik
Giresun Lojistik
Karapürçek Boya Ustası
Şırnak Şehirler Arası Nakliyat
Balıkesir Parça Eşya Taşıma
Adana Parça Eşya Taşıma
Eskişehir Parça Eşya Taşıma
49A61
ReplyDeleteUrfa Parça Eşya Taşıma
Elazığ Evden Eve Nakliyat
Malatya Parça Eşya Taşıma
Coin Nedir
Manisa Parça Eşya Taşıma
Batıkent Fayans Ustası
Şırnak Lojistik
Tekirdağ Şehir İçi Nakliyat
Diyarbakır Evden Eve Nakliyat
4455E
ReplyDeleteVan Şehirler Arası Nakliyat
Karabük Evden Eve Nakliyat
Ãœnye Oto Boya
Trabzon Şehir İçi Nakliyat
Siirt Lojistik
Antep Lojistik
Çerkezköy Motor Ustası
MaraÅŸ Lojistik
Sakarya Parça Eşya Taşıma
3186A
ReplyDeleteBinance'de Kaldıraç Var mı
Raca Coin Hangi Borsada
Btcst Coin Hangi Borsada
Bitcoin MadenciliÄŸi Nedir
Parasız Görüntülü Sohbet
Shinja Coin Hangi Borsada
Spotify Takipçi Hilesi
Binance Ne Zaman Kuruldu
Parasız Görüntülü Sohbet
I highly encourage you to continue sharing informative articles in the future. Your contributions are genuinely beneficial, and we eagerly anticipate learning from and enjoying more of your work. Thank you for your dedication and for expanding our knowledge with your content. Please continue your fantastic work by publishing more informative articles like this. Your efforts are making a notable impact, and we are excited to read more from you in the future. Need finance assignment help? Look no further! Your search culminates here, as we offer unparalleled science assignment help in your vicinity with a roster of over 500 assignment experts. Have questions? Feel free to reach out.
ReplyDeleteA22A2
ReplyDeleteErzurum Ä°ftar Saatleri
Mardin Ä°ftar Saatleri
Isparta Ä°ftar Saatleri
Kars Ä°ftar Saatleri
EskiÅŸehir Ä°ftar Saatleri
Adıyaman İftar Saatleri
Afyonkarahisar Ä°ftar Saatleri
Çanakkale İftar Saatleri
Diyarbakır İftar Saatleri
fdsefgdhbgfjhngjmj
ReplyDeleteشركة رش Øشرات بالاØساء
CBC6A48791
ReplyDeletecialis
steroid satın al
steroid satın al
www.ijuntaxmedikal.store
görüntülü show
skype show
What are your perspectives?